Buffalo Nickel Valued at $786K Million, Might Be Hiding in Your Pocket

The Buffalo Nickel, also known as the Indian Head Nickel, was minted in the United States from 1913 to 1938. This iconic five-cent piece features a Native American profile on the front and an American bison on the reverse.

The design was created by sculptor James Earle Fraser and has become one of the most recognizable and beloved coins among collectors. Its bold imagery honors Native American heritage and the American frontier, making it a standout in U.S. coin history.

The coin was struck primarily at the Philadelphia, Denver, and San Francisco mints. Because of its unique design, it was difficult to mint consistently, leading to various die errors and changes that make specific years and variations incredibly valuable today.

Among these rare issues, some are so scarce and prized that even a circulated piece can be worth thousands—sometimes hundreds of thousands—depending on condition and rarity.

The Truth Behind the $786K Million Valuation

The buzz surrounding a Buffalo Nickel being valued at $786 million stems from exaggerated headlines and viral social media posts. While no single Buffalo Nickel has been officially valued at $786 million by reputable numismatic authorities, there are verified specimens valued up to and beyond $350,000, such as the 1913 Liberty Head Nickel.

Confusion often arises between different coins, especially when discussing rare error coins or early mintings. Still, collectors and treasure hunters are driven by these stories to re-examine their pocket change. The highest-selling Buffalo Nickel to date is the 1913 Liberty Head V Nickel, not the traditional Buffalo design.

However, certain Buffalo Nickels—especially from 1916 with a doubled die obverse or the rare 1937-D “three-legged” buffalo—are worth tens or even hundreds of thousands when in pristine condition. The key takeaway: while the $786 million figure may be inflated, some Buffalo Nickels do hold extreme value and are still hiding in drawers or old coin jars.

Rarest and Most Valuable Buffalo Nickels to Watch For

While many Buffalo Nickels are common, a few rare variations are highly sought after by collectors. The 1913-S Type 2 is one of the rarest and can fetch over $10,000 in high grades. The 1918/7-D overdate is another top contender, with values reaching up to $350,000 at auction for near-perfect specimens.

Then there’s the famous 1937-D “Three-Legged” Buffalo Nickel, caused by a minting error where one of the buffalo’s legs is missing due to over-polishing of the die. This error coin can be worth from $5,000 to $100,000 depending on condition. Coins with strong luster, no signs of wear, and full detail are graded higher and command greater value.

Collectors should also look for varieties like doubled dies, repunched mint marks, and coins struck off-center. These unique features make some Buffalo Nickels far more valuable than their face value and attract serious attention from numismatists worldwide.

How to Identify a High-Value Buffalo Nickel in Your Collection

Identifying a valuable Buffalo Nickel starts with understanding its date, mint mark, and condition. First, check the date on the coin. Coins from 1913–1938 have various value ranges, but specific years and mints like the 1916 doubled die, 1918/7-D overdate, or 1937-D Three-Legged error are among the most valuable.

Look for the mint mark just below the “Five Cents” on the reverse side. A “D” stands for Denver, “S” for San Francisco, and no mint mark indicates Philadelphia. Next, examine the coin’s condition: sharp details on the Native American’s hair and the bison’s horn and tail increase value.

Coins in Mint State (MS), which show no signs of wear, are worth significantly more. You may also use a magnifying glass or a jeweler’s loupe to spot minor die errors or doubling. If you believe you’ve found a rare variety, it’s best to have it professionally graded by a service like PCGS or NGC.

A Table of Noteworthy Buffalo Nickels and Their Estimated Values

Below is a helpful table highlighting some of the most famous and valuable Buffalo Nickels and their estimated worth based on condition and rarity:

Year	Variety/Type	Mint Mark	Key Feature	Estimated Value (High Grade)
1913	Type 2	S	Raised mound removed	$10,000+
1916	Doubled Die Obverse	P	Doubled date	$100,000+
1918	7 Over 8 Overdate	D	Overdate error	$350,000+
1935	Doubled Die Reverse	P	Doubled lettering	$25,000+
1937	Three-Legged Buffalo	D	Missing leg on buffalo	$100,000+

Note: Values are approximate and may vary based on condition and market demand.

Tips for Selling a Rare Buffalo Nickel Safely

If you suspect you have a valuable Buffalo Nickel, don’t rush to sell it at a local pawn shop. The first step is to have the coin authenticated and graded by a reputable third-party grading service like the Professional Coin Grading Service (PCGS) or the Numismatic Guaranty Corporation (NGC).

These services will assess your coin’s authenticity, grade it, and provide a tamper-evident holder with a unique serial number. Once graded, consider listing it on reputable auction sites such as Heritage Auctions or Stack’s Bowers, which specialize in rare coins and attract serious buyers.

Avoid selling on general online marketplaces unless you’re experienced, as scams and undervaluation are common. You can also consult with a certified numismatist or coin dealer to help evaluate your options. Remember, patience is key. A high-value coin like a rare Buffalo Nickel deserves careful handling to ensure you receive its full market worth.

Can a Rare Buffalo Nickel Still Be in Circulation?

Although most rare Buffalo Nickels have likely been pulled from circulation over the decades, there’s still a small chance one could be hiding in a forgotten piggy bank, old coin jar, or inherited collection. It’s less likely to find these coins in everyday change due to their age and collector interest, but it’s not impossible.

Many people who don’t recognize their value may unknowingly spend them or keep them without realizing their worth. Garage sales, estate auctions, and old coin boxes passed down through generations can sometimes yield surprising finds.

Even worn Buffalo Nickels from common years are worth more than face value and can spark curiosity about coin collecting. It’s always worth taking a closer look at those old coins you have lying around. With the right knowledge and a bit of luck, you could uncover a hidden treasure that’s been waiting quietly for decades.

The Cultural Impact and Legacy of the Buffalo Nickel

Beyond its monetary value, the Buffalo Nickel holds a unique place in American history and culture. Designed to honor Native American heritage and the wild frontier, its imagery symbolizes strength, resilience, and identity. The Native American portrait is believed to be a composite of real tribal leaders, while the buffalo was modeled after Black Diamond, a bison in the Central Park Zoo.

The coin gained immense popularity upon release and continues to be featured in modern designs, such as the U.S. Mint’s American Buffalo gold coin series. Its rugged look and artistic design have made it a favorite among artists, collectors, and historians alike.

Even those who aren’t serious coin collectors often recognize and admire the Buffalo Nickel, making it a lasting symbol of American coinage. Its ongoing popularity ensures that rare examples remain highly desirable—and valuable—among numismatists and investors looking for pieces with both financial and historical worth.

A Legendary Coin That Could Still Be Found

While claims of a Buffalo Nickel worth $786 million may be exaggerated, the truth remains that some variations of this iconic coin are indeed worth life-changing amounts. Whether due to minting errors, low mintage, or impeccable preservation, rare Buffalo Nickels can be extremely valuable.

By understanding which coins to look for, where to find them, and how to verify their worth, you position yourself for a potential treasure hunt. Even if you don’t stumble upon a million-dollar specimen, learning about and collecting these historical coins can be a rewarding hobby filled with surprises.

Don’t overlook those old nickels in your change jar—they might just hold a piece of American history and a significant piece of wealth. So, start digging through your coin collection, because the next Buffalo Nickel you find could be worth far more than five cents.

FAQs

Also Read:- The Lincoln Wheat Penny Valued at $2115000: Still in Circulation